Humanism in Post-Job Theology

 To offer an extension of yesterday’s thoughts, I believe this perspective that illness always just happens, and is never judgment for my sin (let me digress: surely these people do not disavow illness as a punishment for sin at times. The issue is that it is the result of my sin, not just an ethereal “someone’s” sin) is fundamentally humanism.

I was in a discussion with one of my roommates and we ended up talking about psychology. We were discussing the role of psychic changes and whether they preceded or followed faulty character. For instance, psychopaths feature a definite change in brain pattern and functionality. They also feature an amazing lack of conscience. Common thought (though unproven) is that the brain changes control the character. In other words, it is not a psychopath’s fault that he has no conscience. However, if we are using the Word Of God as our authority, and we look at Romans 1 (the man who has rejected God) yes, the psychopath may have a brain issue, but it is the result of his rejection of God, not the grounds of it. The view of psychology is a fundamentally humanistic perspective.


In a post-Job theology, the mindset is that sickness just happens. Yes, God saw fit to make me sick, but as was stated yesterday, this is just the roll of the dice. It’s not the result of sin. See, there is no concept of the cause of the sickness. Interpretation of illness (and other such things in life) starts with the man. It doesn’t start with God. This beginning with man is as humanistic as the popular view of the psychopath. It is simply unbiblical.

One thought on “Humanism in Post-Job Theology

  1. You should read Edward Welch’s book “Blame it on the Brain” he is a resource that NANC uses but he does a wonderful job covering the subjects that seem to be interesting you. You may find a great deal of interest in he section on Alzheimer’s disease and the differences in the behavior of those that are saved and those that are not when effected by the disease.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s